Elon Musk faces defamation trial over spat with British diver
3 December 2019, 07:44
The Tesla CEO made a comment about Vernon Unsworth, who helped rescue football players trapped underwater in Thailand.
Elon Musk is going on trial on Tuesday for his troublesome tweets in a defamation case pitting the billionaire against a British diver he allegedly branded a paedophile.
The Tesla CEO will be called to testify early in the case in Los Angeles federal court to explain what he meant when he called Vernon Unsworth – who helped rescue youth soccer players trapped underwater in a Thailand cave – “pedo guy” in a Twitter spat more than a year ago.
Mr Musk later apologised for lashing out at Mr Unsworth on Twitter after the diver belittled Mr Musk’s efforts to build a tiny submarine to save the trapped boys as a “PR stunt”. The tweet, widely interpreted as a reference to a paedophile, was removed by Mr Musk, who disputed that’s what he meant.
“‘Pedo guy’ was a common insult used in South Africa when I was growing up,” Musk said in a court declaration. “It is synonymous with ‘creepy old man’ and is used to insult a person’s appearance and demeanour.”
Mr Unsworth’s lawyers have laughed off that explanation and said his claim was undercut by a subsequent tweet when he said, “Bet ya a signed dollar it’s true”, in response to a question about whether he had accused Mr Unsworth of being a paedophile.
The lawyers also said he hired private investigators to dig up evidence Mr Unsworth was a child molester, which they never found, according to Mr Unsworth’s lawyers.
The lawsuit is not the first time Mr Musk’s tweets have landed him in hot water.
Mr Musk and Tesla reached a $40 million settlement with the Securities and Exchange Commission last year on allegations he misled investors with a tweet declaring he had secured financing to buy out the electric car maker. He agreed in the settlement to have future tweets about the company screened.
He was forced back into court on accusations he violated that agreement by tweeting a misleading figure about how many cars Tesla would manufacture this year.
The SEC sought to hold him in contempt of court, which led to a new agreement imposing tighter controls on Mr Musk’s tweets about the company.
The cave drama played out for more than two weeks in the summer of 2018 when the 12 boys — ages 11-16 — and their soccer coach were trapped in a flooded cave in northern Thailand.
Mr Musk and engineers from his SpaceX rocket company custom built a mini-submarine to help with the rescue. The device was heavily publicised but never used.
Mr Unsworth, a diver and caving expert whose advice was considered crucial in the rescue operation, said the sub would never have fit in the cave’s tight spaces. He told CNN that Mr Musk could “stick his submarine where it hurts”.
Mr Musk responded two days later with his series of tweets.
Mr Musk claims he wasn’t making a factual statement and no one reading his tweet would take it seriously and interpret it as defamatory.
Despite removing the tweets, he later suggested in emails to the news website BuzzFeed that Mr Unsworth was a “child rapist” and had moved to northern Thailand to take “a child bride who was about 12 years old at the time”. He provided no evidence.
Mr Unsworth is seeking unspecified damages for pain, suffering and emotional distress.
The defence has resisted efforts to turn over financial records to show Mr Musk’s wealth but has stipulated his net worth exceeds $20 billion (£10.57 billion).